The hierarchy of consistency strengths for membership in a computably enumerable set, Oxford Logic Seminar, May 2025

 This will be a talk for the Logic Seminar at the Mathematical Institute of the University of Oxford, 29 May 2025 5pm Andrew Wiles Building.

Abstract. For a given computably enumerable set π‘Š, consider the spectrum of assertions of the form π‘› βˆˆπ‘Š. If π‘Š is c.e. but not computably decidable, it is easy to see that many of these statements will be independent of PA, for otherwise we could decide π‘Š by searching for proofs of π‘› βˆ‰π‘Š. In this work, we investigate the possible hierarchies of consistency strengths that arise. For example, there is a c.e. set 𝑄 for which the consistency strengths of the assertions π‘› βˆˆπ‘„ are linearly ordered like the rational line. More generally, I shall prove that every computable preorder relation on the natural numbers is realized exactly as the hierarchy of consistency strength for the membership statements 𝑛 βˆˆπ‘Š of some computably enumerable set π‘Š. After this, we shall consider the c.e. preorder relations. This is joint work with Atticus Stonestrom (Notre Dame).